#13: What Happens If You Cause a Car Accident?
What happens if you cause a car accident? Will your insurance cover the damages? What should you do if someone sues you?
In this episode of Off the Record with Gerstner Adam Law, attorneys Paul Adam and Colin Gerstner take a different approach to their usual conversations about personal injury law. Instead of focusing on the person injured in a car accident, they discuss what happens to the driver who caused the crash.
From the moments immediately following an accident to dealing with insurance companies, settlement demands, and potential lawsuits, Paul and Colin explain what at-fault drivers should know to protect themselves and avoid making costly mistakes.
They discuss why reporting an accident to the police and notifying your insurance company are important, what it means to cooperate with an insurance investigation, and why refusing to disclose your insurance policy limits could complicate a claim.
The conversation also covers preserving evidence, the risks of posting about an accident on social media, and what to do if you’re served with a lawsuit. Paul and Colin explain the difference between an insurance company’s duty to defend and duty to indemnify, including what can happen when an insurer refuses to provide coverage.
In This Episode, We Cover:
🚗 What to do immediately after causing a car accident
🚨 Why calling the police and documenting the crash matter
🤝 How to interact with the other driver after an accident
📋 Why you should exchange insurance information and avoid settling at the scene
📞 When and how to notify your insurance company
⚖️ What happens if you refuse to cooperate with your insurance adjuster
📊 How vehicle event data recorders (black boxes) can help establish what happened
💰 What insurance policy limits mean and why the injured party may request them
📝 Why disclosing your insurance limits could help avoid a lawsuit
📱 The dangers of deleting text messages, photos, or social media posts after an accident
🔍 What spoliation of evidence means under Montana law
🤝 How insurance companies negotiate settlements on behalf of at-fault drivers
📬 What to do if you’re served with a summons and complaint
👨⚖️ Who pays for your defense attorney when you’re sued
🛡️ The difference between an insurance company’s duty to defend and duty to indemnify
⚠️ What happens when your insurance company denies coverage or refuses to defend you
Whether you’ve recently been involved in a car accident, want to understand how auto insurance protects you, or are concerned about being sued after a crash, this episode provides practical insight into the legal and insurance processes that may follow.
⚖️ Connect with Gerstner Adam Law
🌐 Website → https://www.gerstnerlawoffice.com/
👨⚖️ Paul Adam → https://www.gerstnerlawoffice.com/legal-team/paul-adam/
👨⚖️ Colin Gerstner → https://www.gerstnerlawoffice.com/legal-team/colin-gerstner/
🎙️ More Off the Record Episodes → https://www.gerstnerlawoffice.com/podcast-2/
📚 Additional Resources
🚗 Montana Department of Justice – Motor Vehicle Division → https://dojmt.gov/driving/
🛡️ Montana Commissioner of Securities and Insurance → https://csimt.gov/
🚘 National Highway Traffic Safety Administration → https://www.nhtsa.gov/
👍 Like this episode if you found this information helpful.
💬 Comment below: What’s one question you’ve always had about auto insurance or car accident claims?
🔔 Subscribe for more conversations about Montana law, personal injury claims, insurance coverage, and your legal rights.
Disclaimer: This podcast is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Insurance coverage and legal obligations depend on the facts, applicable law, and individual policy terms.
#OffTheRecordPodcast #GerstnerAdamLaw #MontanaLaw #CarAccident #AutoInsurance #PersonalInjuryLaw #InsuranceClaims #BillingsMontana #InsuranceCoverage #LegalAdvice
Transcript
Introduction: What happens when you’re at fault?
PAUL ADAM — 0:07
Welcome back to another episode of Off the Record, Gerstner Adam Law Podcast. My name is Paul Adam. It’s my partner Colin Gerstner.
So, Colin, today we’re talking about auto accidents, like we’ve talked about several episodes already, although this is an interesting twist on it because this is going to be from the perspective of the person who is at fault in the accident.
COLIN GERSTNER — 0:34
Correct. So we represent the victims of car accidents. We call it plaintiffs, or the person who got hurt who’s not at fault.
But what spurred this is I’ve gotten several calls, as it turns out, from people close to me. I won’t identify them, of course, but they actually were the at-fault party in a crash.
And one person called me afterwards panicking, didn’t know what to do. Another one did after they got a letter from the claimant’s attorney, who’s also a good friend of mine, wondering if they should ignore it, should hire their own attorney, what do they need to do after getting a letter from the injured party’s attorney saying that they’re asserting the claim?
So that’s what spurred this topic.
To be clear, we don’t represent defendants in civil actions. We don’t represent people who are at fault for the crash. As we get into, the insurance company will retain those attorneys. So we don’t, to be clear.
But as we’ll discuss, oftentimes the injured party and the at-fault driver really have a common interest in getting the insurance company to resolve these claims.
What to do immediately after causing an accident
PAUL ADAM — 1:47
Yeah, and so let’s just go into a hypothetical here, Colin.
I’ll play the role of the automobile driver, and let’s just call it a rear-end. I think that’s maybe the most common auto accident out there.
It’s not these catastrophic injury-causing T-bone wrecks. It’s maybe a fender bender where you just were distracted and you hit somebody.
So if I hit you, Colin, I’m driving behind you.
COLIN GERSTNER — 2:20
You got the Huskers game pulled up on your phone. You’re distracted.
PAUL ADAM — 2:24
I’m weeping tears. It’s probably because I’ve got tears in my eyes and I’ve been crying because of that.
But I rear-end you, and so we’re both stopped.
I think probably the first thing goes without saying, pull off to the side of the road.
I mean, you immediately create a hazard if you stay in the middle of the road with traffic coming.
So get to a safe place. Make sure the person that you hit, if your cars are drivable, can also get to a safe place.
COLIN GERSTNER — 2:58
Correct. And then you call 911, get police out there.
PAUL ADAM — 3:04
Why is that?
And so I think that’s interesting because a lot of folks, if it’s a fender bender and no one appears hurt, I think a lot of people aren’t inclined to call the cops.
COLIN GERSTNER — 3:19
Yeah. So we’ve had cases where that has happened, where what they think is a relatively small crash, they feel hurt, jarred.
But a lot of us don’t like confrontation, right? And so they don’t want to involve the police.
They think it’s not a big deal. They just get your phone number, and we’ll sort out later. Want to get out of there.
PAUL ADAM — 3:40
Yeah.
COLIN GERSTNER — 3:41
But always call the police. We want that crash report out there.
Typically, you’re obligated under the law to report crashes to the police. I don’t have the dollar amount off the top of my head, but anytime there’s an injury or property damage up to a certain amount, you have to call the police.
And if they show up and say it’s not my concern, then whatever, not your business.
But we do want to at least make that call and get them out there.
PAUL ADAM — 4:07
Yeah. I mean, we’ve had a handful of clients where if there’s no police report, if there’s no crash investigation, there always ends up being a question of liability, and it’s a he-said-she-said.
And if there’s injuries involved, then the stakes are pretty high.
And so it’s usually parties that regret not having called the police.
COLIN GERSTNER — 4:35
So you call 911, get the police out there, and then you can check on the other driver.
Unfortunately, there’s this perception where you don’t want to interact with the other guy.
It’s okay to be a decent person. And so in this situation, Paul, it’s okay for you to get out, assuming you’re okay.
But if you notice I’m banged up a little bit, it’s okay to come over, check on me, render first aid if you have to.
Again, don’t move them if they can’t move unless there’s a fire, some sort of immediate danger.
But it’s okay to be a good guy. You don’t have to be so guarded, right?
PAUL ADAM — 5:11
Yeah.
COLIN GERSTNER — 5:11
Be a good person.
Exchanging insurance information and documenting the crash
PAUL ADAM — 5:12
So let’s say the cars were drivable. You get them off the road. People can move enough that you can get and check on each other.
Nothing’s life-threatening, and so the scene is safe.
And so I come up to you. Next step is probably exchanging insurance information.
COLIN GERSTNER — 5:34
Yeah, I think next step is, well, depends. The police are there.
Just be honest and plead with the police, just involving the facts, right? Tell them what happened.
If you don’t know an answer to a question that’s asked of you, tell them you don’t know. It’s okay.
Don’t guess or speculate as to what happened with the other drivers unless you know.
PAUL ADAM — 5:57
And I will say, as just an aside here, from the perspective of a witness, if you see a crash, most people are busy.
You’re on your way to work. You’re on the way to pick up kids, or doing something.
It is so important to have a witness statement in a crash report, especially if it looks bad.
So that’s just my little quip to stop. Give a statement.
It’s okay to be listed on a police report. It’s okay if you’re a named witness.
I just think that’s an important human thing to do.
COLIN GERSTNER — 6:36
So typically, in the cases we see, they involve injuries, and the person’s typically taken by ambulance.
So it’s not a traditional exchange of information like we’re talking driver’s ed, or you back into somebody in a parking lot, dent their car. Then you just give them your insurance card.
But yeah, if you’re able to give them your insurance information, let them take a picture of your proof of insurance.
But typically you give that to the officer, and it’ll make its way into the crash report.
Don’t settle with anybody at the scene.
You won’t believe stories we’ve heard, offering cash at the time to settle it to keep it off insurance.
Again, people, for whatever reason, always want to keep it off insurance, which begs the question, why get insurance in the first place if you’re trying to keep it off?
Don’t try to settle it outside of insurance. You most definitely don’t want to settle or pay for anything right there at the scene.
Notifying your insurance company
PAUL ADAM — 7:35
Yeah. So the cops have come, information’s been exchanged, people go on their way, whether by ambulance or if the car is drivable, you leave.
So the next steps are really where the claims are initiated. Would you say that’s right?
COLIN GERSTNER — 7:54
Yeah. So then I would call your own insurance company and tell them what happened.
Well, you’re probably wanting to get a property claim on your own car. Presumably, it’s damaged. You want them to fix that, and then you also want to give them notice that there is a potential claim against you.
It’s important to do that.
Your policy will require notice given when you know of a potential claim.
Late notice might give the carrier a chance to argue prejudice, keeps them from evaluating the case.
So I would just report it, and then you have a claim open.
PAUL ADAM — 8:28
So I would say the next step then would be cooperation with your own insurance company, right?
COLIN GERSTNER — 8:33
Correct.
So these insurance policies have cooperation clauses where you’re obligated to cooperate with your own insurance company, and that could mean giving a recorded statement, producing documents, otherwise just answering their questions.
So when your own insurance company calls you, answer it and tell them what they need to know.
Again, don’t speculate or anything. Just answer truthfully and completely to your own personal knowledge.
Refusing can put your own coverage at risk, is the takeaway.
If you ignore them, then ultimately your insurance may deny coverage due to your lack of cooperation, and your own personal assets might be at risk.
Vehicle black boxes and telling the truth
PAUL ADAM — 9:17
And I will say, the truth is out there.
I don’t think a lot of people know about EDR data, but if you’ve got a vehicle that was from the mid-’90s or newer, it’s going to have a black box that records all of your driving, your braking, your lights, your acceleration, your deceleration.
It’s going to record all of that data, and if liability does become contentious, that data is going to be pulled by an expert, and there is the truth.
And so you just got to be upfront about exactly what happened, because there’s no hiding that EDR data.
COLIN GERSTNER — 10:01
Correct.
We always tell our clients this, whether it’s a court statement if we’re giving one, or deposition, or court testimony.
We always tell the truth, right?
Let the facts come out as they may. We’ll deal with them from there.
But we never want to try to manipulate the story or spin it by telling half-truths or make assertions that you can’t back up factually.
Understanding insurance policy limits
PAUL ADAM — 10:23
So then, Colin, let’s say that now we’re a month in.
I hit you a month ago now, and presumably you’re receiving treatment, wherever that is.
I don’t really know about what’s going on. I’ve probably talked to the insurance adjuster one time.
I’ve probably moved on in my head from whatever’s happening, but all of a sudden, I get a call from my insurance company saying, “Paul, will you give your permission to disclose the policy limits of your liability policy?”
And I’m like, well, what the heck?
I’ve got a $100,000 liability limit on my truck. I thought this was just a fender bender.
Why do they care about my liability limits?
What would your recommendation be in what I say?
COLIN GERSTNER — 11:22
I would always disclose your policy limits.
It’s something that we can find out anyway in litigation.
And so what the other side wants to know is they want to know what their potential recovery is against your own policy, not you personally, but against your insurance company.
And so what happens? In this case, my attorney, a very retained one, is trying to evaluate whether they should send a settlement demand, or if they just need to sue you.
And in order to know whether we should settle, we really need to know the policy limits.
If we don’t know, at least in our firm, if we don’t know the limits, play the situation out.
So if you were to say, “Don’t tell my limits.”
PAUL ADAM — 12:02
Yeah, right. Why?
No, this was a fender bender. You don’t need, I’m not going to tell you how much you can recover.
I don’t want you asking for all that money. That’s ridiculous.
COLIN GERSTNER — 12:11
No. So then my attorney would probably sue you, and then in litigation, we’re going to find out that limit anyway.
And so I don’t get why some people don’t.
It’s actually kind of rare. I’d say maybe 10% of the time the insured or the at-fault party refuses to disclose limits.
PAUL ADAM — 12:34
Well, I think the inference is that, oh, that person is trying to get all of the money that my policy allows.
They don’t deserve $100,000 for a fender bender. They’re asking for all of the money.
I think that’s the inference, and that’s just not what’s going on.
COLIN GERSTNER — 12:51
No, you’re exactly right. That’s the mentality people have.
The funny part is, it’s not your money, man. It’s the insurance company’s money, and they’ll pay a settlement up to the limit.
And so I wish they would get out of their minds that this is their money.
It’s not.
And furthermore, I don’t know if I’ve had a case where insurance companies give me more money than my client deserves.
And so it’s not your role to evaluate this claim, right?
And you’re not saying necessarily that the injury victim is going to get your full limit.
You’re just giving them permission to know what the limit is.
PAUL ADAM — 13:34
Yeah, I would say that’s probably, if you get that phone call and you are the at-fault party, and you’re asked to disclose your policy limits, that is a crossroads right there.
Or a pretty big indicator on whether or not you are going to get a complaint and summons served on you in the next few weeks if you say no.
COLIN GERSTNER — 13:58
Correct.
And this is a situation where it’s a little counterintuitive for people to think about.
But in this situation, really, the claimant and the at-fault party have a common interest in settling this thing before litigation.
Nobody wants to get sued.
Nobody wants to talk to even their own defense attorney, sit for a deposition if they can avoid it, and the injured party is in the same boat.
Our clients never ask to be part of a lawsuit, right?
And so ideally, you’re hurt, there’s high enough limits, you make a settlement demand and resolve it for somewhere within policy limits, and there’s no court action, and both parties just get to move on with their lives.
Preserving evidence after a car accident
PAUL ADAM — 14:45
I want to talk a bit about preservation of evidence.
And I think that’s also something where if I hit you, I don’t know what’s going on with the case.
I don’t know that there’s any problems. I’ve moved on with my life.
Maybe I got a new phone. Maybe I sold my truck, the one that was damaged that was involved in the accident.
What are some of the pitfalls there in terms of preservation of evidence?
COLIN GERSTNER — 15:20
So you should always preserve evidence of the crash and the injuries afterwards.
PAUL ADAM — 15:27
But what if I don’t?
What if I never listened to the Gerstner Adam podcast and I didn’t know any better, and I’m like, well, no one told me.
No one told me I can’t wipe my phone or I can’t sell my truck.
What’s the remedy, I guess, on the other side?
COLIN GERSTNER — 15:45
Yeah. So in Montana law, there’s a separate tort or cause of action called spoliation.
That’s called spoliation of evidence.
It can actually come in two forms. One is as a separate cause of action against you.
So if you’re in a crash and you get sued for it, you’ll typically be sued for what we call negligence.
You’re driving negligently.
There can be another added on there for spoliation.
It can also be a sanction in discovery, right?
So let’s say you texted your buddies, took some pictures, and then find there’s a claim against you, and you’re like, oh shit.
And you say, “Oh crap! I can’t believe I told my buddy that I was at fault for this crash. I better delete this text message or all these pictures. I’m just going to delete them.”
That comes out later. You can get a court order against you and get in quite a bit of trouble.
Social media mistakes that can hurt your case
PAUL ADAM — 16:37
Yeah. What about, I don’t think this is on your outline that we prepared for today, but it just came to mind.
Everybody’s online, everybody has social media.
Social media is a pretty big part of discovery anymore, and there’s some pretty damning things out there that we’ve seen working for us and against us on the plaintiff side.
What would be your recommendation in terms of social media? What to post? What not to post? The problems there.
COLIN GERSTNER — 17:17
I always joke the number one rule of posting on social media is don’t.
But generally speaking, my clients don’t. I mean, it’s such part of our lives, right? It’s how you follow each other.
I have a hard time recommending to stay off social media altogether.
But don’t post anything related to your injuries or the accident.
And if I’m speaking to the at-fault drivers, as much as I’d love to have a defendant admitting to causing the crash on social media, I just, my recommendation would be don’t post anything about it.
If you do post, you absolutely cannot delete it.
And so we have this conversation all the time with clients where they’ll post things online, and then it makes them look bad.
Maybe they’re doing activities that may make them look more active than they are, and the first temptation is like, “Oh, I’m going to delete this post.”
You have to tell them, “No, you can’t.”
You can set your settings to private, so it’s not publicly viewable, but you can’t delete anything.
PAUL ADAM — 18:25
Yeah, and if you do post about it, just playing it out through litigation and through discovery, if you’re posting things that are relevant to the accident, those are discoverable.
And you’re gonna then spend one evening downloading your Facebook history and your message history for relevant messages and chats and texts or whatever it is.
And it’s really nice when we have a client on our side where that question comes up and they’re like, “Oh, I get posts once a year on my birthday, and I hit the like button.”
And there’s nothing there.
It just makes discovery a breeze, makes the whole case easier.
So that’s best practice on both sides.
And this isn’t indefinitely. It’s not like you caused an accident, you should close your social media for good, right?
COLIN GERSTNER — 19:29
Yeah, and again, I’m not saying never log on to Facebook, don’t like your buddy’s pictures, anything like that.
Eventually, this case will close, whether statute of limitations has passed or there is a claim and it’s settled.
It’d be weird at that point, years later, to post something about finally getting something off your chest and describing the accident.
That’d be odd, but eventually the claim will be over, I guess.
But I imagine at that point it’s moot, and you’re not going to post anything related to the crash anyway.
How insurance companies settle accident claims
PAUL ADAM — 20:04
How involved are defendants in closing that claim and in that final resolution?
And I guess what would be your advice in your participation? Should you be involved in how that claim ultimately resolves?
COLIN GERSTNER — 20:24
So if it settles pre-litigation, you’re probably not involved at all.
PAUL ADAM — 20:28
Yeah.
COLIN GERSTNER — 20:29
And so using our scenario where you injure me, my attorney, a hired attorney, they’ll be in communication with your insurance company.
And let’s say, I’m just going to make up numbers here, you have a $100,000 liability limit.
Let’s say it settles for $60,000 for whatever reason.
That is negotiated between me and your insurance company.
PAUL ADAM — 20:52
Yeah.
COLIN GERSTNER — 20:53
And I don’t know for sure. I think you get notice that it’s settled.
They might tell you after the fact, but they don’t need your permission.
Your car insurance company does not need your permission to settle a case.
So even if you think I’m making it up or being a fraud, that’s not your decision to make.
That’s the insurance company’s.
What to do if you’re served with a lawsuit
PAUL ADAM — 21:13
But let’s say the claim doesn’t settle, okay?
And those attorneys, well, let’s say you don’t even have an attorney on your side. It’s just the adjuster.
But let’s say the plaintiff’s attorney and your adjuster can’t agree to a number, and the other side sues you.
And so you do get a complaint and a summons served on you.
And you might get that from a process server. You might get that from the sheriff’s office.
Anyone over 18 can really be a process server.
But what are the steps there? Because I think that causes a lot of panic.
Most folks have never been sued, and that’s a moment of panic.
If you get a knock on the door from a cop and they hand you the paperwork, what do you do next?
COLIN GERSTNER — 22:04
Yeah, so you let your insurance company know immediately.
So there are what we call the two duties that the insurance company owes you.
The first is to indemnify, which is a duty to settle your claim within policy limits, if it’s warranted.
The second one is a defense.
And so if you’re sued, your insurance company has to retain an attorney to defend you.
You don’t pay the attorney out of pocket.
They have a panel. They have defense firms that they use, and they will hire somebody for you.
And so let your insurance company know. They’ll hire a defense attorney, and that attorney will take it from there.
Who pays for your defense attorney?
PAUL ADAM — 22:47
So what if I, though, let’s say I’m a business owner, and I use an attorney all the time in my day-to-day operations of my business.
And I’m like, well, there’s only one attorney in town that I trust, and it’s this guy at this firm, and that’s who I want to represent me because I just got sued.
Should I call that attorney and get them on board or not?
It’s not clear if you have a choice.
COLIN GERSTNER — 23:19
So in a car crash situation, you don’t.
The policies give the insurance company basically sole discretion to pick your attorney, and the panels, and most of them will be just fine for you.
Some, you’re talking about business owners, so there’s some malpractice policies that allow typically a doctor or somebody professional to pick their attorney.
So the panel provides an option.
You can pick your attorney at the insurance company’s expense, and they’ll negotiate the rate between them, or the insurance company has a panel of attorneys they like for whatever reason to represent you.
PAUL ADAM — 24:01
Yeah, and I think the biggest factor here to remember is you do not have to pay an attorney to represent you if you get sued.
The insurance company pays for that defense.
And so if you go out and seek your own attorney and hire them and circumvent that process, well, you’re going to be paying legal bills when you don’t have to.
COLIN GERSTNER — 24:23
Yep. Yeah.
So this is the exact call I had with somebody I know who wanted to hire me after they knew there was a claim against them.
And I told them, “No, you don’t want to pay me hourly. If you need an attorney, your insurance company will hire one for you.”
PAUL ADAM — 24:41
Yeah.
COLIN GERSTNER — 24:41
And this is getting in the weeds a little bit, but a really interesting aspect of Montana law, which is fairly unique, I believe, is that your insurance-retained attorney actually owes you the exclusive duty, right?
So even though the insurance company is paying their bills, they don’t represent the insurance company. They represent you.
PAUL ADAM — 25:03
Colin, you are getting into a whole, this is a topic that we could have a whole other podcast on.
COLIN GERSTNER — 25:09
Yeah.
PAUL ADAM — 25:09
But I will say, Colin, you are a wizard at these next steps, and I can tell where you’re going with this because you love to talk about the difference between duty to defend and duty to indemnify, and what happens when an insurance company gets this stuff wrong.
The duty to defend and duty to indemnify
COLIN GERSTNER — 25:28
Okay, I’ll try to be brief.
I don’t know if I want to get in the weeds too far.
I want to hear your 30-second bit.
So there’s a couple things I want to say.
Oftentimes, you’ve hurt somebody, and you want them to settle.
Look, we all get insurance, auto insurance, for a reason.
That’s because we know we’re human. People make mistakes.
I try to be as careful as I can while driving, but I’d be lying if I said there weren’t times I drove too fast, or I was distracted by something.
And I’m not going to sit here and say I’m never going to cause an accident because we all might.
And so we purchase car insurance to cover us and also somebody that we may hurt, right?
And so if we injure somebody, I really hope that my car insurance will compensate the victim for whatever they’re owed.
PAUL ADAM — 26:21
Yeah.
COLIN GERSTNER — 26:22
And so, knock on wood, I’m never in the situation.
But if I am, I’m going to be telling my insurance company, “Settle it. Pay them up to my limit. Whatever you think is fair. I don’t want to be sued. Settle it.”
And if I get sued, I’m going to reiterate to my insurance company, “Hey, settle it. Make this thing go away.”
I’m not going to say, “Don’t pay them a dime. Let’s take them to court,” right?
It’s not my call. I want this case resolved, and so I’m going to be telling them to.
PAUL ADAM — 26:52
Yeah.
COLIN GERSTNER — 26:53
The second part, which I think you want to get all fired up about, I’ll be quick, is the duty to defend.
So if a complaint potentially lists a covered action against you, your insurance company has to hire an attorney to defend you.
It’s called the duty to defend.
If they breach that duty, it can be good for the claimant and potentially bad for the defense.
So what it is, is that the insurance company is saying you’re on your own.
Your own assets are at risk. You gotta pay for an attorney yourself, and if you want to settle it, it’s gonna come out of your own pocket.
What happens if your insurance company denies coverage?
PAUL ADAM — 27:36
And so that’s gonna come across in a phone call where, when you get served with a complaint and a summons, and you make that call to your insurance company and say, “Oh great, can you tender a defense? I just got sued.”
If they come back and they say, “Shoot, Paul, you don’t have coverage,” or “That’s not covered under our policy.”
Well, shoot, I thought it was. I thought I was protected. I thought I had coverage.
I would say that’s where you kind of shift back over into the plaintiff side of things.
And so throughout that whole process, you have been a defendant in a case where you are the at-fault party.
As soon as that insurance company turns on you and says, “Yeah, we don’t think we’re going to defend you. We don’t think you have coverage,” that’s when we want to hear from you.
COLIN GERSTNER — 28:39
Yeah, I would let the plaintiff’s attorney know.
Again, you don’t have to have a substantive discussion of the case, but you can tell them, “Look, I tendered this to my carrier.”
The insurance company will send you a denial letter. Forward that to the plaintiff’s attorney.
Then probably hire counsel of your own, coverage counsel, we call it, to help you evaluate whether you have a claim against your own insurance company.
And we won’t get into it this episode, but you can negotiate a stipulated judgment, a covenant not to execute, whereby the plaintiff can then sue your own insurance company.
These are all things that attorneys can work out.
But yeah, if your insurance company leaves you high and dry, it’s okay to let the plaintiff’s attorney know that.
Closing: A future episode on insurance bad faith
PAUL ADAM — 29:31
Yeah. So for anybody listening, if you’re still listening and this has got your ears perked up, and you’re like, oh, insurance bad faith, and that interests you, we’ve got to have a part two of this episode, I think.
And I think that’s going to be a perfect segue for what we talk about next time.
How do you feel about that, Colin?
COLIN GERSTNER — 29:53
Beautiful.
PAUL ADAM — 29:53
All right. Excellent.
Thanks so much for listening. It’s been a Gerstner Adam Law podcast, Off the Record. Appreciate you.






